...against fictions and other tall tales

Sunday, 29 January 2012

Interest rates and the housing bubble

In a recent post, Prof. Krugman seems to suggest that the Fed's low interest rates were to blame for the bubble in housing. I side with Robert Shiller on this issue:
The interest rate cuts cannot explain the general nine-year upward trend that we have seen in the housing market. The housing boom period was three times as long as the period of low interest rates, and the housing boom was accelerating when the Fed was increasing interest rates in 1999. Moreover, long-term interest rates, which determine the rates for fixed-rate conventional mortgages, did not respond in any substantial way to these rate cuts until the late stages of the boom. (2008:49)
Visually, this is what Shiller is pointing to (click to enlarge):

Source: Federal Reserve

Now, you can blame the regulators (and their political leaders) for having failed to stem the flow of toxic mortgages by setting prudent mortgage-lending standards, as I did in an earlier column. But to suggest that the Fed's low interest rates created the bubble is not right. On this point, the Financial Crisis Commission made it very clear: excess liquidity did not cause the bubble; rather, it was the failures in financial regulation and supervision that are to blame, including the "failure to effectively rein in the excesses in the mortgage and financial markets". (2011:xxvi)


National Commission on the Causes of the Financial and Economic Crisis in the US, The Financial Crisis Inquiry Report, Public Affairs: New York, 2011

Shiller, R., The Subprime Solution, Princeton Press: Princeton and Oxford, 2008


  1. Nod! circuit. You did what Schiller didn't do-challenge the critic on the premise. In any case, the critic should have checked Schiller's work before tabling the thesis, and go to the secondary reference FCIR for backup.

    1. BREAKING NEWS: USD Currency Collapse

      China Causes The USD To Fall?

      USD Dollar Drops 50% In Value Overnight?

      Hey there

      I don’t know you have heard this yet…

      But the USD Dollar is on the verge of collapse.

      In fact since 1973 it’s been on a downward trend…


      USD national debt is at an all time high and now financial experts are saying that China is starting to sell their debt holdings to the secondary market.

      This means it won’t be too long until the USD crumbles in value!

      >>Watch This Video To Learn More<<

      I don’t want to be the bringer of bad news, but this is seriously not good for the US since we already have domestic problems of our own, such as immigration and unemployment.

      Our economy can not withstand another hit.

      This time the USD might actually collapse.

      >>Watch This Video To Learn More<<

      Make sure you watch it before it’s taken offline.

      Speak soon.

      [Mr Mark Fidelman]

  2. Shiller knows what he's talking about. I'm not sure what the critic has to gain in saying the Fed caused all this. In my mind, that's like giving a free pass to those who were really at fault. Speaking of whom, this reminds me of something I read not long ago on the Bank of Canada site. I consider it the first law of banking:

    "Prudence on the part of individuals and financial institutions is the first line of defence against this risk. Households need to ensure that, in the future, they will be able to service the debts they take on today. For their part, financial institutions are responsible for appropriately assessing risk, as well as the ability of clients to service their debts." Household debt backgrounder

    The last sentence is the kicker, in my view.

  3. Thank you for sharing such great information.
    It is informative, can you help me in finding out more detail on
    housing loan interest.

  4. ASSETDATA บ้านจัดสรร บ้านจัดสรรภูเก็ต PHUKET VILLA วิลล่าภูเก็ต โครงการบ้านภูเก็ต VILLA POO VILLA บ้าน Villas Phuket Sale Villa PHUKET VILLA